Legault Refuses Curfew Exception For Homeless After Man Dies In Montreal

MONTREAL — Quebec Premier Francois Legault says he won’t grant a curfew exemption for Montreal’s homeless population, telling reporters Tuesday he has confidence that police will use their good judgment in dealing with cases.

Legault told reporters during a COVID-19 briefing in Montreal that altering the government’s decree to exclude the homeless from the provincial curfew would be used as a loophole by others to flout the measure.

Montreal’s mayor had made the formal request just an hour earlier, calling on Quebec to relax the COVID-19 measure on the city’s most vulnerable population.

“What I’m say is right now, the police are doing a very good job. They use their judgment,” Legault said. “If we change the rules and say that you can’t give a ticket to someone who is saying they’re homeless, you may have some people that will pretend to be homeless.” 

Montreal Mayor Valerie Plante’s appeal followed the weekend death of Raphael “Napa” Andre, a 51-year-old Innu man found dead in a portable toilet not far from a shelter he frequented. Andre often spent time at a day centre for the homeless called The Open Door, which was forced to close its overnight service last month following a COVID-19 outbreak.

He visited the centre Saturday evening and was found dead Sunday morning, not far from the shelter, which had to send him out at 9:30 p.m.

The coroner is investigating Andre’s death.

Plante said there’s evidence the curfew is causing problems for the homeless and those who work with them. “What we’ve been seeing in the past week is that it created a lot of stress — not only for the homeless population itself but also the workers,” Plante told reporters outside Montreal City Hall.

“The curfew just adds to that and creates a sense of insecurity for a lot of users and we don’t want that,” the mayor said. “I want people to feel safe in the streets.”

Plante said the 8 p.m. to 5 a.m. curfew — which began Jan. 9 and is scheduled to last at least until Feb. 8 — is creating an untenable situation for the city’s most vulnerable. 

Legault said police aren’t there to ticket homeless people, but they can direct them to homeless shelters. Plante agreed Montreal police have shown compassion, noting they had helped at least 400 homeless people find shelter.

The mayor says the city’s overnight shelters are at least 95 per cent full on most nights. While she wants the rules relaxed to relieve the pressure, she doesn’t want people sleeping on the street.

“I want people to have access to a bed, a place where it’s warm, where there’s food, where there’s services for them,” she said.

Plante said a 100-bed facility is set to open in the coming days. Legault said the province has added 800 beds and it stands ready to add more as needed.

This report by The Canadian Press was first published Jan. 19, 2021.

Also on HuffPost: